Friday, 30 July, 2010
 

AskWizard

Site Search

Your home of Tech Help on the Net

Do laptop coolers work?

Friday, 30 October, 2009

OLDER QUESTION

I’ve been using my laptop PC quite a lot lately, and I’ve noticed it gets quite hot sometimes. With hotter weather coming would it be worthwhile to buy a laptop cooler like the Antec Notebook Cooler?

Thanks,

(Originally posted January 2005)

Alan Hay, Sunshine, VIC


Spending money definitely wouldn’t be MY first course of action!

The first thing to consider is – do you actually have a problem? Laptops are a lot of components crammed into a small area and, despite the fact that they use low power consumption components, they tend to get warmish. If your laptop is running stably without locking up and crashing then it’s fine. You’ll get system instability before the thing keels over and dies! As long as you don’t leave it running unattended beside a heater or near a window with the sun beaming in on it I wouldn’t worry too much about it feeling warm to the touch.

If the temperature of the unit is making you feel uncomfortable, or if you begin to suffer system instability as it warms up, there’s another trick to try before spending money on a solution. Laptop coolers, whether it’s the Antec unit or some other, all have one thing in common as well as cooling fans. They raise the laptop above the work surface. That, in itself, will assist the cooling of your laptop.

Cut yourself a couple of small slats from wood or some other scrap material, just large enough to sit under the rubber ‘feet’ of your laptop and raise the unit a couple of centimetres above the desk surface. You’ll most likely find that does just as good a job as a laptop cooler will!

(I'd like to add a couple of pints to what Terry has said,.
  1. If the computer is running hot, I would get a cooler. I'd get the sort that uses a combination of fan and lifting the unit clear of the desk.
  2. If you do get one, try to get one that runs from an external power source and not USB from the PC.
  3. As an emergency cooler, I've been known to use a wire cake-cooler.
-Paul Zucker)

Cheers,

Terry O'Shanassy


Reader solutions



brionyPosted: 11/05/2010

re: Do laptop coolers work?
i couldnt live without mine as the hades 3 gets too hot on my lap potherwise.
TiredPosted: 09/02/2010

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Laptop coolers are a last resort to an overheating laptop. If your laptop is really hot, i recomend these three things. (do 1 first, through)
1. Clean out laptop vent.
2. (if still hot) grab a laptop cooler if you don't mind using it on a desk
3. (if even still too hot and overheating) try to Under volt (google it) your Cpu, and or Under clock Cpu/Gpu.

My Toshiba a200 has a tendancy to get really really hot. If your Toshiba Satelite is an a200, Do not think about taking it apart. You WILL end up with more screws then you started with. Toshiba are not the best at constructing a diy laptop. For rip apart-ability, i recommend Asus.

dahsyattulPosted: 21/01/2010

re: Do laptop coolers work?
my answer is yes.i counter the same problem before.then i bought an external laptop cooler for $15 and the problem was solved.now, i try to upgrade the external cooler that i bought from 2 fans to 3 fans.hope that my laptop can last to 3 more years.hehe
SamPosted: 09/01/2010

re: Do laptop coolers work?
It's a good idea to consider 'undervolting' your laptop as well (won't damage the hardware or void your warranty). There are a few great guides floating round on the net - worth checking out. I managed to shave off 13 degrees my maximum.
ShaunPosted: 14/12/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I have the infamous Dell Studio XPS 16 which has a GPU that runs at temps above 90C when playing games causing the GPU to reduce its activity lvls putting the stress onto the CPU resulting in serious lag.

After simply elevating the back of the notebook 1 inch off the table surface I was able to reduce the temp to 75C.

In this case I think creating air space for the fans/vents under the notebook is effective enough and would recommend prioritizing this over a cooler, especially one that offers no extra gap between the notebook and the surface.

That being said I am currently in the process of finding a quality cooler that will do both.

MarcPosted: 09/12/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
After reading many of these postings I decided to do some experimenting with my Compaq laptop and the USB powered Antec cooler that I purchased for it. My laptop has two internal fans which run independently of each other based on the machine's cooling needs and these observations were made running the laptop on AC power with the battery removed, room temperature 70F. Sitting flat on my wood desk both internal fans came on within a short period and ran nonstop for several hours, I then placed the Antec cooler under the laptop but did not plug it in. After about 20 minutes one of the two internal fans stopped running and the laptop continued to run on one fan with the second fan kicking on and off intermittently for the next couple of hours. Finally, I plugged in the cooler's USB cord and turned on the fans. After 30 minutes the laptop was running one internal fan and the second was no longer kicking on and off. Draw your own conclusions.

(Thanks for the experiment and report Marc. -PZ)

FrankPosted: 06/11/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Anything is better than actually sitting them on your lap and burning yourself or smothering the intake and extraction vents on any sort of fabric.

A hard surface or cooler tablet is a definate good choice.
Frank n St31n

johnnoPosted: 02/11/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
got a elcheepo stand for my laptop from a cheap shop and i have a fan blowing air towards it and my self and it let the air flow under the latop i paid $5 plus it can be folded up and placed in ur laptop bag and taken with u
FREDRIKPosted: 01/11/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
YOU MUST KEEP YOUR MACHINE TEMP DOWN OR YOU WILL BREAK IT, SIMPLE AS THAT. YES COOLING PADS DO THAT JOB
MikePPosted: 01/11/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
First point. If you are using the laptop in an office on mains power, remove the battery, you don■t need it. Batteries generate heat when being charged; removing the battery will reduce some heat input
Next point. If you are using the machine on battery and not on a desk, ensure you do not obstruct ANY vents in the base. Use a hard surface to rest it on. Not only must the laptop exhaust vents be unobstructed but the air INTAKE vents must remain clear so that you have airflow through the machine

Remember, Fans do NOT cool. All they do is move air. What any ■cooler■ is doing is just moving heated air from the source and allowing it to be replaced by air at an ambient temperature. (I am excluding from this any refrigerating cooler to avoid unnecessary comment)
What this means is, the higher the ambient temperature, the less efficient your ■cooler■ will be, and, for any ■cooler■ to work it must be able to draw the heated air from the laptop and exhaust it adequately to atmosphere.
In answer to the specific question, Yes, If the ambient temperature is less than the laptop AND the ■cooler■ has an induction port in proximity to the laptop vents AND the ■cooler■ airspeed is greater than the laptop airspeed the ■Cooler■ should allow the laptop to run at a lower temperature.
Whether it■s worthwhile, economic or practical; your choice.

(Good tips. -PZ)

UshanPosted: 30/10/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
well this will clear all the clouds of confusion; laptop tends to generate a lot of heat from the bottom bit, esp the part where there is the battery and processors; so if you keep your laptop on a wooden or insulated surface you are risking your system to be overheated; sometimes even keeping it elivated doesn't do the job, because not enough air circulation happens. Me play a lot of 1080P files and my laptop is 2.16 dual core processor; if i dont put a table fan in front of it, bitch starts to scream like a c***; that is the 1080p file lags kind starts to lag with the audio and it video frame rate drops. So i ended up buying me Thermaltake CLN008, it does its job like it should. Had to pay off 60 bucks for the shipment from USA to Australia.. lofl, but its worth it; laptop coolers is most needed for people who puts their laptop at its beasty best often. Unless you dont use too much of CPU power like watching 1080P stuffs or playing games and in bonus in summer you happen to stay in a chilled room; than dont spend your hard earned cash in here, go buy a bunch of burger or sth. Hope this will help.. cheers

(Keep the gutter language at your place please Ushan. -PZ)

ericPosted: 14/01/2009

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I have a laptop cooler and wondering if it does work? I downloaded (download.com) to show me the actual core temperature at my sidebar. most of the time I dont notice the difference. It seems the bottome of my laptop is cooler but the reading on the cores(dual core) is the same. Im wondering if its really cooling my laptop.

(But more to the point, as long as the notebook isn't overheating. -PZ)

BrianPosted: 14/12/2008

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I recently bought a laptop cooler for my Sony Viao (sic). It wasn't getting extremely hot before, but I just wanted to be on the safe side. It was a gigaware. Cheap, Lightweight, and gets the job done

I got one for 12 bucks at a Radioshack because of ones they had left over from black friday. I am very pleased with the result for the money. It is sturdy and I can notice a difference.

I would say it is worth it, Unless you are doing hardcore gaming don't feel that you have to spend an arm and a leg on a cooler.

NgocPosted: 09/11/2008

re: Do laptop coolers work?
My laptop is 2 years old. Building up a bit of storage in here, but it generally works fine. Whenever it heats up or run on long periods however, it starts to lag. A LOT.
Sometimes it gets to the point that the machine automatically crashes.
Did a bit of research, looked at some prices. Going to get myself one tomorrow. Weigh it up .. how much does a cooler cost? How much would it cost if ur laptop crashed, completely? Risk im not taking
Steve Van VurenPosted: 02/09/2008

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I have an Antec cooler for every laptop in the house (4). I have to believe that any extra air that is drawn out of the bottom of the laptop and dispersed out the side has to be good for the unit. Heat destroys electronics no matter what. If it didn't why would there be a fan installed in every computer on the market. Having an extra fan to protect the investment is far cheaper than the frustration when heat destroys it. My opinon....yes they work, and they work great.
Your "lap" stays cooler too!!
RalphPosted: 31/08/2008

re: Do laptop coolers work?
It seems coolers may avoid chips inside laptops from warming up , but may not cool down them. (I use CPUID-HM to monitor built in sensors)

I have an Antec cooler, old model, it blows air down ( not the sides as new model does). It is a great help with my old laptop wich has its own fan intake by the side, but not much of help with new laptop with fan intake at the bottom: it seems hot air is taken in, and running the cooler fan does not help, indeed chipset heat goes up by 1 or 2 Celsius deegres !! Laptops should be designed with fan intake on the sides, not at the bottom.

JasonPosted: 15/07/2008

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Ted.

It's called WD40, is your laptop still under warranty? If not take the bottom panel off, remove the sticker on top of the fan and try and Jerry the fan housing plug off, put a DROP of WD40 in there, just a drop, lube the fan (move it around) then add another drop, while your at it, dust off your heatsinks.

(Hi Jason. As far as I know all those WD spray products evapotrate without leaving anything behind. That is, they act as a lubricant for a while, but soon they're all gone and you're back to where you were. That's why they're called Water Displacement sprays. -PZ)

WaynePosted: 12/03/2008

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Powered fan Coolers do not work efficiently ,the laptop requires a cool surface, not your lap,
The vents must not be blocked.
For extreme hot days while playing a game which requires high graphics ,you can use a hicepack wrapped in a Tshirt placed under the laptop,be sure to check from time to time that the Tshirt is not wet.
Gary JacobsPosted: 08/12/2007

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I use a lapdesk which has a bean bag side on one side and a hard surface on the other. Works great when I use my laptop on my lap. Keeps my lap cool and provides for air circulation.
GrnotherPosted: 03/06/2007

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Seems there are 2 things for laptop coolers to do: 1) Keep lap cooler; 2) COOL DOWN actual laptop. Most reviews talk about how much cooler their laps are with a certain brand cooler. Few talk about how cool the actual laptop is, i.e., how cool the HD and CPU, and even RAM, can become.
Little is demonstrated about how actually cool the CPU becomes, e.g., use Speedfan??

One solution IS consistent, raise the laptop up so air passes under it. And, the cooling fans in the laptop coolers have a limit--and since they are designed to push air up and out UNDER the laptop, the fans must be close to the bottom of the laptop.

Possible design: Make use of the "Northbridge" pure cooper passive heat-transfer heat sinks, e.g., or CPU heat sinks [see, e.g., Enzotech Pure Copper Heat Sinks] or even CPU Heat sinks with fans inside the copper heatsinks. Have the copper material come in direct contact with the base of the laptop that is hottest, or other areas that produce heat--and draw away heat, have the fans further blow the heat away. These heatsinks can raise the laptop up so air circulate underneath. Any laptop coolers with their fans might do this just as well. Use these copper coolers seated on these laptop coolers now made, and let the copper heat sinks draw the heat away from laptop base, therefore, CPU, etc.

Something in this general design might be more efficient, COMBINING use of air flow, heat conduction through copper, and keeping the laptop base cooler on the lap. Laptop can still be tilted for best keyboard position.

JamesPosted: 03/03/2007

re: Do laptop coolers work?
My toshiba has been giving me trouble for months.

First I thought it was spyware killing the machine. It seemed as though there was no method to its madness as to when it turned itself off. Sometimes whenI was doing nothing but reading email and something when a specific action took place like me starting an audio or video.

I decided to restore the laptop to original settings and this took a while as it kept crashing.

Then it seemed like it wouldn't crash any more(maybe I was in an air conditioned room) and then bam the same crap over and over.

So today I decided I would try to blow out the dust off the fans and the heat sink( I guess that is what the little copper wirey looking thing in the back is).

Well it has been working good so far and I added a chillmat just for good measure.

It has been running for an hour so far. Also I found a setting in the toshiba power manager that I swear I set to max performance. but it was set to silent mode. This basically controls how much the fan runs and I wll see when I restart the computer if it defaults back to silent mode.

BTW, when I blew the dust out there was MUCH more than I could see by lookin into the laptop. I would blow it out and it looked clean. I blew it out again and more dust flew out. Did it about 3 times before I didn't see dust coming out anymore.

Hope this helps me and readers that follow.

JonoPosted: 09/01/2007

re: Do laptop coolers work?
i find raising my laptop off a surface works fine!

just put sumthing under the back lip to tilt it up and foward and ur set! works a treat

but during this hot spell, iv been playnig games in a cooler room with a fan rite infront of me (behind the laptop) more to keep me cool, but i found it also kept the laptop running at like50 degrees rather than 70+...(even though 70 is quite safe) just a thought i spose

jono

kelPosted: 10/03/2006

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I like to sit my fan behind my HP laptop it has a venttalation port at the back for that purpose,so i inhance it a little, works great the with it raised works even better,
Michael AllanPosted: 07/01/2006

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Isn't there a problem with gravity when you raise the back of the Laptop and not the front, that can make the Hard Drive wear out! This is why all computers are made flat, to keep Hard Drives 90 or 180?
AdamPosted: 04/01/2006

re: Do laptop coolers work? YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I bought an antec notebook cooler at the markets for $39 and now when i lift the notebook (Dell) off of the cooler and feel the bottom of it it hardly gets warm. Before it used to get VERY hot and used to lock up. Only need it in summer, but it works great. USB powered, but I plug it into a USB Hub ive got.
VaughanPosted: 29/12/2005

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Please remember that laptop computers are so called as they can fit on your lap, but are not designed to be operated there. Just ensure there is adequate ventilation, and unobstructed free space under and around your laptop.
StevePosted: 25/12/2005

re: Do laptop coolers work?
My Compaq laptop is ok during winter but gets very hot during summer. I got the side cover off an old PC and bent one end over to make a stand for the rear of the laptop, letting air circulate underneath. Took less than a minute and does the job.
Andrew BriscoePosted: 23/12/2005

re: Do laptop coolers work?
another suggestion is to sit in a cold room -- i had an external harddrive attached to my laptop and both generated alot of heat then i put on the aircon and it isnt even warm most of the time (26C), i suggest pputting the aircon on if ur going to be using it for long periods of time in the summer
GrahamPosted: 19/12/2005

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I have a venerable Inspiron 1100 well known for overheating. All the Dell forums suggested re-applying thermal grease between the heat sink & CPU. There were easy online instructions with pictures. This fixed my problem.
andrew peter collinsPosted: 19/12/2005

re: Do laptop coolers work?
Alan. as i've said before, common sense must prevail when using "any" electronic gear. nothing electronic is efficient and the side effect of this is heat. for example, incandescent lights exploit this when they give off light. in other words they heat up. when using any gear, say to yourself "is there a better way or place to use a laptop to safe guard it against thermal runaway?" if any gear feels too hot to touch, can you imagine how hot the individual component must be IE: a power transister in a power amp is a great example. i often get called out to fix gear, sometimes when a club is actually open and the power amps for the subs (bass) are so bloody hot you could fry an egg on the chassis. can you imagine how hot the individual components inside the amp are but some club owners just don't care. the owners sure do when, thwack, oh fertiliser. busy night, no audio. nuff sedd cheers Andy :) :) :)
ReaderPosted: 18/12/2005

re: Do laptop coolers work?
I have a cooler I bought at the markets for $32. It sits on the desk and I only use it when the PC is at home. I could of got one with extra plugs and sockets as well.
TedPosted: 18/12/2005

re: Do laptop coolers work?
My toshiba satelite was running very hot and eventually the fan started making a noise then stopped and now the PC only works for a coupl of minutes before locking up

Post your own solution to this article

Your name:

Email:

Subject:

Your post:

 
© 2010 ACP Magazines Ltd. All rights reserved.