Friday, 30 July, 2010
 

AskWizard

Site Search

Your home of Tech Help on the Net

Dead notebook but no Windows

Monday, 16 November, 2009

I bought a Medion laptop in April 2007.

It is now six months out of warranty and the hard drive has failed. I couldn't even recover my data with specialised file recovery software.

Worse still' the machine came without a Windows disk -- the installation files were stored in the D partition of the hard drive. I have purchased a new hard drive' and I emailed Medion a week ago to ask how I get a copy of the operating system that I paid for with my laptop. Zero response.

Looks like I have to go out and buy a new copy of Windows. DON'T BUY MEDION !!

Boyd Willis, South Brisbane, QLD' Australia


You don;t need me to point out the obvious Boyd' but since you've written in to talk about this problem...

Did the machine offer a method of creating a recovery disc? It probably did' so who is responsible? If the handbook advises you to create a recovery disc as soon as you unpack the PC' shouldn't you?

And how many times do you hear people saying that backup is the most important part of using a PC. It costs very little to buy an external backup hard disk.

Anyway' that's water under the bridge. Perhaps now is the time to buy and install Windows 7.

Paul Zucker


Reader solutions



cumagutzaPosted: 18/11/2009

re: Dead notebook but no Windows
I learnt a long time ago to visit the manufacturer's website and look at what they offer in the way of support.

They will offer the basic support for their market. Support costs money.

In your case, if they didn't want repeat business by at least trying to SELL you a recovery disk, yes, they are not looking for repeat business. Maybe your request got lost or forgotten-about. If the possibility is there to "take advantage" of your circumstance after the warranty runs out, expect a dent in your credit card. Even while the system is still under warranty they would ask you to send your system back...wait...wait...wait, then you will have a new system (a new HDD and your data is gone, they don't rescue data).

At least you have tried to rescue your data, but as mentioned, you need backup. Imagine that your HDD is going to fail tomorrow. Me, I only try to recover data for other people, if my system fails I have my data backed-up. I reinstall Windows and (any) software I want and start again with a fresh system. I don't mind starting again, the system is as fast or faster than the old one (if it is slower, you're in trouble, see below).

If you install a retail version of Windows, will you have the correct drivers? Where could you get the correct drivers? Suggestions of pirated Windows wouldn't get you any further, you will still be running Windows basic installation drivers.

Matt

Carlo SchisanoPosted: 17/11/2009

re: Dead notebook but no Windows
Are people blind, stupid or both? How many times must I hear people mention this scenario?

Every stinking laptop you buy either comes with a recovery partition, recovery CD's or Windows CD. PERIOD! If your laptop comes with a CD then thats your copy of Windows, otherwise if you have a recovery partition, the laptop has proprietary software to help you create recovery media.

You COULD read the manual. You COULD refuse to ignore THAT BIG BLOODY MESSAGE THAT TELLS YOU TO CREATE THE RECOVERY MEDIA WHEN YOU FIRST BOOT IT UP...But you are too much of an ignorant sack of bones to do that and you blame every single person on God's green Earth except for yourself.

Every single person that puts themselves in this situation needs to be king-slapped Marshall-style like in How I Met Your Mother.

And to C Smith (hope youre not my mate Cameron!), I have opened at least one laptop from just about every manufacturer and have never come across this issue that you mention. So unless your friend is buying dodgy laptops from residential backyards in the saddest parts of China, then what you are saying is total bull.

C. SmithPosted: 17/11/2009

re: Dead notebook but no Windows
I know of a laptop owner who lost two HDD on two individual laptops. Neither brand offered recovery disc function. When the install partition was lost that was it. He now happilly runs them with pirate copies of XP. He gets along just fine without updates etc. I have always enjoyed the Toshiba experience . . . Toshiba at least allows recovery discs. Could change if they get greedy . . .

Post your own solution to this article

Your name:

Email:

Subject:

Your post:

 
© 2010 ACP Magazines Ltd. All rights reserved.